Honey Pot
Wendy was a Chinese student attending a large state university in Texas. She was sharp, pretty, and sociable, and had many friends, Chinese and American. In her junior year, she decided to live with an American friend, Karen, whom she had met in her apartment complex; they shared a small apartment, not too far from the university. Before they moved in together, they had become friends, talking about boys they had crushes on. Wendy had a crush on a guy named Peter, a Chinese graduate student, who lived in an apartment complex nearby. Karen had a crush on a guy named Brad, a handsome but irresponsible undergraduate.
Unfortunately, soon after they moved in together, Brad and Karen went out together for a short time, and then Brad dumped her unceremoniously. He ignored her texts. He treated her poorly when they met. He made it clear it wasn’t going to work. Karen was heartbroken, and spent almost a month in bed, it seemed to Wendy. She stayed home, ate too much, and watched a lot of television in her room. She was still friendly to Wendy, but she was clearly depressed. Wendy worried about her.
Meanwhile, Wendy wasn’t having much luck with Peter, either. Peter was a researcher in social media, and his project involved what was called “honey pots,” social media accounts which attracted spammers and people who were using social media for illicit purposes. Wendy wanted to learn more about what Peter did and what he studied, as she used social media and was interested in it. But Peter and the people he worked with were very busy, and hard to get to know. She became more involved in the Chinese Student Association, hoping that he would attend, or that she would meet more people that knew him. Apparently, from what she heard, he did have a friend, Ming, who lived in his apartment complex, and who would often make him dumplings, but it was unclear to Wendy whether Ming was a girlfriend, or just a friend. Most of the people she met considered them just friends, but it was hard to tell with this kind of relationship, and she didn’t necessarily trust other people’s judgment. She seethed inside with jealousy. She wanted to be the one who made dumplings for Peter. She wanted to attract his attention, and she set about to do what she could to get in his path, so he would notice her.
Wendy would often think about Peter and his situation, and Karen and hers, while she was out picking up pecans. One thing her Chinese friends had found out was that there were lots of delicious pecans that fell from trees in the neighborhood where they lived, and people in Texas didn’t care about them; if you asked, they would often let you pick as many as you wanted. And pecans had become extremely valuable in China. When they had a friend going back to China, they could put a couple of pounds of pecans in their luggage, and it would be considered a valuable treat back in China. Wendy and several friends happily sought them out and picked them in their free time, and then shelled them, although you could get them shelled very cheaply. This had come to occupy parts of Wendy’s weekends.
About a month after Brad had broken up with Karen, Karen brought a woman named Lee over to the house. Wendy was pretty sure Lee was a woman, but not positive, because she dressed in a very male-like way and acted male. Wendy found herself doubting; she doubted her own knowledge of American males and females, of cultural conventions, of the sounds of voices. But Wendy, actually, had been in the states for several years, was pretty aware of this kind of thing, and still, upon watching Lee, got many mixed messages. Lee was male in many ways, and female in many others. And that was true both physically, emotionally, in every way, it seemed. She was stocky, and had a calm voice. Her hair was short on the sides with a kind of wild top. She had a calm voice that could be either male or female. Her eyes were always calm, with a great amount of control.
They sat down and talked for a while at the kitchen table; Wendy studied Lee a little. Lee was very calm and collected; if she had great desire for Karen, she didn’t show it. Lee was the one who first presented the concept of “genderqueer” to Wendy. This was the rejection of the idea that everyone was either strongly male, or strongly female; one could be in between, or could fluctuate. Lee told about this calmly, unemotionally. Karen was clearly very interested in the idea. To Wendy, it seemed possible, but probably wasn’t true for her. She had always felt like a woman, and still did.
It was not clear to Wendy whether Karen and Lee were having an affair; if they were, they kept it hidden from Wendy. Lee came over a lot, but usually in the day, or on weekends, and Lee and Karen went out together. They were clearly close, and Lee was introducing Karen to a whole new crowd of people. They had friends who were transgender; they’d changed, from male to female, or the other way; they had many friends who were gay, and everyone who hung around with this crowd knew that and was comfortable with it. Karen herself talked more and more like Lee; she made herself look male, or at least ambisexual, and she gave away a number of girlish things, like necklaces and earrings, many of them to Wendy. Wendy and Karen were still good friends. Wendy asked Karen about what was happening one night, and they talked for quite a while.
Karen said she felt it was unfair that society forced you into being entirely male or entirely female, when in fact the reality for many people, herself included, was much fuzzier. She didn’t feel entirely male or entirely female; she felt in between, some days one, other days the other, and a kind of in-between identity was actually what she was most comfortable with. The good thing, she said, about her new friends, was that they were accepting of this. She described gays and transsexuals who felt strongly about their sexual orientation, and weren’t ambivalent at all, as she was, but at least they could relate to the feeling of society pushing something on them that they weren’t. All of her new friends, tired of being misjudged by society, at least had that in common.
After her talk with Karen, Wendy had a long Skype chat with her mother, in which she told her mother the basic details of what was Karen had told her. Her mother was actually very supportive of both Karen and Wendy, and not especially critical, either of Karen’s choice of friends, or of Wendy’s. She said that you should remember that everyone has problems; no one is as happy as they seem. In fact, she said, her own problem was that she had lost any sexual desire at all, and it wasn’t really Wendy’s father’s fault; he was as nice and as charming as he’d always been. She just had reached a point where she just didn’t have any sexual desire. She told this to Wendy matter-of-factly, as if it could happen to anyone.
This totally confounded Wendy, and she lost a night of sleep after that conversation. It was partly that she had never considered her parents as sexual beings in the first place, much less people who could change, or have doubts about their identity, or not be what they’d always been to her. She was very unsettled, and felt a little unsure about what to do now.
Her feelings for Peter, however, were as strong as ever. She still had a huge crush on him. She still felt totally sure she was a woman, and she still felt he was the man she really wanted to meet and get to know, and she continued trying to do that.
Finally, one night, she got her chance. The Chinese Student Association was having a party and almost everyone she knew was there. Peter was there, and Wendy was pretty sure that Ming was there as well, though she wasn’t sure she’d know Ming if she saw her. The woman Wendy identified as Ming acted like a friend of Peter’s, but perhaps not a girlfriend; it was hard to tell. Wendy proceeded with caution, knowing she was being watched. But she couldn’t resist starting up a conversation with Peter, and getting him to talk about his research.
This was when she heard about the honey pot. Peter claimed that the object of his study was to use social media sites to find people who were preying on normal social media users, and study them - study their methods. He called them “content polluters” and occasionally referred to the different kinds: spammers, malware distributors, etc. His specialty, he said, as she watched him carefully, was harvesting and identifying these content polluters, in spite of what he called “strategic polluter obfuscation.” This, he explained, was their deliberate attempt to appear to be like real people, or real friends, or genuinely social beings.
As Peter talked, Wendy admired him. To her, he was a kind of god, so handsome, so smart, so successful in his research. All she could think of was how to find a way to get him to be hers. Suddenly, as they sat there, she had an idea. She was holding a pecan candy that one of her friends had made from the pecans they had picked. She held it up to him and claimed, right there, that she made delicious pecan candies herself, and if he ever wanted some, she’d be glad to bring him some.
He was a little taken aback, as he’d been involved in explaining his project, and it was hard for him to switch gears. He liked the idea that anyone would be willing to make candy for him, but unfortunately, he didn’t do what she wanted: give her an invitation, or provide an address, or even a phone number or way to get in touch with him. She was still a little traditional about that; she didn’t want to blurt out her own phone number, or social media account, as she considered that a little too forward. Their conversation moved on, and eventually he went off to talk to another friend, who was in his graduate department. She was frustrated. Perhaps she’d made her offer too early, or hadn’t provided the right incentive. To her, pecan candies were delicious. How could anyone refuse?
Wendy was further frustrated, not having his phone number, or an open invitation to just bring him some pecan treats. But she had been serious about making them, and within a week had found a good recipe, bought the ingredients, and made some acceptable pecan candies. She had a little container of them ready for him. Finally she couldn’t resist, and found his Twitter account. She had known about it all along, but simply hadn’t used it; now, she wrote him a quick message saying she had something for him if he wanted it. The message said, “have those treats I told u about - let me know when u want some.” She put his name in the tweet and very little else. She thought it was pretty straightforward – using “u” instead of “you,” but otherwise just a normal message. Later, she would go back and look at the message to see what was wrong with it: perhaps he didn’t like the use of “u”? At the time that she wrote it, though, it seemed like it was just a normal message. She flung it off and tried to go back to her studies.
That night, Karen came home in tears, and Wendy had another long talk with her. It was not clear to Wendy whether Lee was a love interest or not, to Karen, but in any case, she didn’t want to talk about Lee. The group she had been hanging around with was doing very crazy things: having wild parties, going to various bars, doing self-destructive drugs. Karen could see this clearly enough and was trying to get some distance; she had done a bit of this recently herself, but tonight, she’d had enough, and had come home instead.
Wendy studied Karen a little as she talked. Wendy considered Karen pretty, and could see, from talking to her, a sense of stress and self-doubt. Wendy thought she was still upset about Brad. But Karen got mad when she suggested that; she said that was suggesting that all pain had to come from men. She was still determined to have a life that was more free of gender expectations and traditional relationships. In the course of the evening, Wendy heard many new words: besides genderqueer, there were cisgender, gender fluid, pansexual, trans, and a few others. When she heard them she had to ask Karen what they meant, and Karen would have to patiently explain. Wendy was sure that there were people of all genders in China, though she hadn’t known about them, or imagined there were so many names for them. Together they talked for several hours; they made a pot of tea, and she ate several homemade pecan candies listening to Karen talk about her life.
One of Karen’s points, which Wendy found very interesting, was that because society often shunned LGBTQ+ people (Karen made a point of adding the plus), they often went down various rebellious, self-destructive paths, sheerly because of self-loathing, and this was far more destructive than simply experimenting sexually, or being unsure of what one really wanted, which was what Karen seemed to be going through. She said, and she’d said this more than once, that if society let people do what they wanted, and define themselves the way they wanted, everyone would be a whole lot happier. Wendy couldn’t help but think of “society” as Chinese society, with its rigid sex roles; to her, the U.S. already seemed somewhat easygoing in comparison. In other words, Wendy wondered, who exactly was forcing any sex role on Karen? In a college town, almost nobody, it seemed. But Wendy wasn’t a huge consumer of American media, and didn’t expect to fit into American society when she graduated; she was an outsider. She didn’t challenge Karen’s assertion. She was a good listener, and simply listened to Karen’s story of becoming disillusioned with her crowd.
During this time Wendy was almost completely absorbed in her social media accounts, looking for some sign that Peter had replied, but there was nothing. No reply on Twitter; no effort to friend her on Facebook. Nothing. She was crushed. She felt like sending another message, but didn’t. She had already gone too far, she thought. Peter was on her mind a lot. But she had heard nothing from him at all, and it was beginning to irritate her.
About a week later Karen disappeared altogether; she moved out, leaving much of her belongings, but clearly taking what was most valuable to her. She left a note to Wendy promising to pay the rent for the rest of the lease. She was dropping out of school, she said, and going home. Wendy found this hard to believe, but had little choice but to carry on without her, hoping she’d pay the rent. After about a week, she started using Karen’s room for storing pecans.
After about ten days, Lee came over, angry, and demanded to see Karen. Wendy had never seen Lee angry; it had always seemed to her that Lee had been calm and unemotional. Wendy wouldn’t let her in the door; whatever Lee wanted, she’d have to go through Karen, and Karen was gone, she said. They stood at the doorway, neither moving. What surprised Wendy about this encounter was seeing Lee in a completely emotional condition, when, having known her for weeks, she had never seen her express any strong emotion, love, hate, passion, or anything. It was another side of her. And now, it was clear that Lee definitely had strong feelings for Karen. She wanted to see her; she demanded it, now; she wanted an address; she wanted to see her things. Wendy wouldn’t budge. If you give me a phone number, she said, I’ll tell her, and perhaps she’ll call you.
Things were tense, but finally Lee left, and Wendy locked the door. There were pecans all over the house; Wendy and her friends had been using the front room and Karen’s bedroom to store them. From then on, she kept the door locked and kept her eye out for suspicious activity. What few things Karen had left in the apartment, she guarded; she felt like protecting Karen from Lee and from that kind of encounter. When Karen called, she told her of Lee coming over, but Karen didn’t want her number, and said she wouldn’t call it anyway. Eventually Karen came back, with a truck, and picked up the last of her belongings. Wendy studied her, grateful that they were still friends, and gave her some pecan candies.
It was a bad semester for Wendy, not because of her grades so much, but because she never did hear from Peter, and the whole obsession with him seemed to cloud the entire semester. She had felt sorry for Karen, who lost a whole semester as well, and who may not ever come back to the university, as upset as she was. When she called her mother, her mother helped her put it in perspective. Get another roommate, her mother said. Stop fixating on older graduate students who are probably taken, she added. Her mother was interested in the pecan candies, though, and asked Wendy to bring some home, the next time she came.
In fact, the pecans and the pecan candies turned out to be the only good thing about the semester; they were good because, when Wendy and her friends finally did go home, at the end of the semester, people were overjoyed to see them and try them. People came from around their apartment village to try them, as if she had brought home pure gold or the finest of foods.
It wasn’t until much later, back in Texas again, that Wendy found out, from a friend, that Peter had actually mistaken her tweet for that of a content polluter, and “harvested” it. It was not clear whether he actually judged her as a “content polluter” or not, but he’d been so wrapped up in what he was doing, that he was unable to just see her tweet as simply a tweet from a friend. According to this friend, Ming was not part of the picture; Ming had disappeared, and had been gone for a while. Wendy was insulted by the picture of Peter, so engrossed in his study that he couldn’t see Wendy as a friend; it was partly because she had invested so much into the whole effort: the recipes, the candies, the process. But in the end, she followed her mother’s advice. She tried to forget about him, and move on.
His “Honey Pot” study was published, and became well known; it was all over the university’s PR system, and even made it to the newsletter of the Chinese Student Association. Peter had a kind of celebrity, and was known as the “Honey Pot researcher.” Wendy cringed, every time she heard it.
(2-17)